The Board Code. Mantas Šukevičius: “Today, It’s No Longer Enough to Say, ‘I’ve Done This Before’”
We continue our interview series, “The Board Code”, featuring independent board members of state-owned enterprises (SOEs). Five questions – five opportunities to gain a closer insight into their professional journeys, the behind-the-scenes realities of board work, the challenges they face, and the experiences worth sharing.
This time, our guest in “The Board Code” series is Mantas Šukevičius, Chairman of the Supervisory Board of the Business Development Fund (Ukraine), independent board member of AB Lithuanian Airports, and member of supervisory and management boards in Lithuania, Ukraine, and Uzbekistan.
With extensive international experience in the finance and banking sectors, he shares his insights into how SOE board member selection processes have evolved, why professional experience alone is no longer enough for candidates, and what distinguishes Lithuania’s selection system in an international context. M. Šukevičius also discusses the role of an independent board member, the relationship with shareholders, and why the ability to ask difficult questions is an important part of professional SOE governance.
You have served on SOE boards for several years and have participated in board member selection processes on numerous occasions. How have these processes changed since your first applications? What is expected of candidates today that was not required before?
Looking back at my first selection processes and comparing them with those of today, the first thing I can say is that I now prepare much more thoroughly than I used to. My expectations of myself have increased, and I have also developed a clear understanding that competition is considerable – you want to perform not just well, but as well as possible.
Fundamentally, the selection processes themselves remain the same – candidates have access to information about available positions and are free to apply. I believe this aspect of the process is very well organised in Lithuania. When speaking with colleagues from other countries, I notice that they do not always have the same level of openness and access to information about ongoing selection processes.
On the other hand, greater attention is now paid to the professional organisation of the process, and selection procedures have become more structured. Previously, a candidate’s public profile may have carried greater weight, whereas today there is a much clearer focus on the governance competencies a candidate possesses, the competencies a particular company needs, and how the candidate would complement the other board members.
Another observation from my experience is that selection committees want to hear how candidates see their own role in the company’s governance: what knowledge, experience, and proposals they would bring to the board.
In other words, today it is no longer enough to say, “I’ve done this before.” You need to explain what value that experience would create for the specific company.
There is also greater emphasis on the ability to look beyond one’s own area of expertise and understand the company as a whole – its strategy, risks, finances, and relationships with shareholders and management. A board member must not only be an expert in their field but also someone capable of making decisions in a broader context.
What does a candidate need to demonstrate to the selection committee today to be appointed to the board of a particular SOE?
I believe candidates must first demonstrate that they understand the company and the context in which it operates, and prove that they possess the competencies the company specifically needs. It is also important that their experience complements the board and helps it make decisions in different situations. In other words, candidates need not only expertise in a particular field but also a broad perspective.
Developing this understanding requires thoroughly reviewing the available information about the company, familiarising oneself with the legislation governing its sector, and keeping track of the broader economic situation both in Lithuania and internationally.
That is why sufficient time and attention must be devoted to preparing for a selection interview. Personally, I find it helpful to identify in advance the key messages I would like to communicate to the selection committee about what I could contribute if entrusted with responsibilities in that particular company.
Of course, simple but essential qualities such as sound judgement, common sense, education, and the ability to communicate respectfully and professionally are equally important.
I probably cannot identify a specific situation that determined my selection to one board or another – that is for the selection committee to decide, and its decision is likely based on the entire interview rather than any single moment.
However, I can say that on more than one occasion I have risked being “unpopular” by openly pointing out what I consider negative aspects of a company’s operations or the State’s role in it. For me, it is important not only to identify what I believe is wrong but also to offer suggestions on what could be done differently and how the situation could be improved.
Is it clear during selection processes which competencies a particular SOE needs and how your experience matches those expectations?
Today, the requirements for candidates are formulated quite clearly. They are developed in consultation with the existing board, the shareholder, and the Governance Coordination Centre.
I doubt there are many experts or gurus left who could describe the required competencies in a fundamentally different way. In many cases, the requirements are genuinely high, particularly when compared with those for many other elected or appointed positions in the public sector or companies.
Personally, I apply to boards where two things align: I find the company interesting, and I believe I can make a meaningful contribution. I always assess my capabilities and how well I meet the selection criteria.
My extensive experience in banking and finance across different countries has allowed me to develop a broad understanding of various industries and businesses. I therefore try to make the most of this strength and focus primarily on competencies in finance, audit, and risk management.
For me, the goal is not to apply simply for the sake of applying, but to see that my experience could genuinely benefit a particular company.
There is still a perception in public discussions that appointments to SOE boards are based on personal connections. Based on your experience of selection processes, what would you say to someone who holds this view?
It is no secret that I have had similar thoughts myself. When I was applying unsuccessfully for three or four years, I also thought that SOE boards were largely occupied by well-known public figures or people with the right connections.
However, I was probably also developing as a professional during that period. Unsuccessful applications forced me to take a more critical look at myself, analyse the situation, and assess where I needed to improve. Eventually, this approach paid off – I was selected for my first board position.
Therefore, based on my personal experience, I can say that SOE board member selection processes in Lithuania are considerably more professional and transparent than is sometimes assumed. Information about vacancies is accessible to candidates, and decisions are made not by a single individual but by a selection committee comprising representatives of different institutions.
I believe that BICG, the Governance Coordination Centre, and the ministries exercising ownership rights and responsibilities have accomplished a great deal in strengthening SOE governance in recent years. I sincerely hope that this system will remain transparent and competitive and that its integrity will not be compromised.
Yes, there are occasional comments in public discussions that the same people appear on multiple SOE boards. However, based on my own experience, I can say that board work is my professional activity. I provide my knowledge, experience, and time as a professional service. I see nothing wrong with my “product” – my competencies and experience – meeting the needs of a particular company.
Have you ever encountered a situation where the shareholder’s expectations differed from what the board considered to be the best decision for the company? How should an independent board member act in such circumstances?
When discussing SOEs, we must always remember the fundamental question: why is a particular company state-owned? What market limitations is it intended to address? Is it an activity that private businesses could perform more efficiently? Has the company been entrusted with strategically important national interests or projects? Or are there other reasons?
Once the company’s role is understood, the shareholder’s expectations also become clearer. In my view, an expectation is not an order – it is more of a guideline that, provided there is a good relationship with the shareholder, the board can discuss constructively, clarify, or, where necessary, explain why a particular expectation may not fully align with the company’s operations, strategy, or mission.
My experience shows that ministries cooperate quite constructively with the boards of the enterprises they oversee when discussing expectations, coordinating Letters of Expectations, and considering proposals from boards.
Differences of opinion can arise, particularly when fundamental decisions are involved, but I have not personally encountered any openly confrontational situations.
In such circumstances, an independent board member should act independently and ethically, assess the consequences of the decision for the company and society, and seek a constructive solution.
There is considerable debate about whose interests should take priority in such situations – those of the company, society, or the shareholder. I do not believe there is a single universal answer that applies to every possible situation. Each case must be assessed in light of the company’s purpose, strategy, applicable legislation, and the consequences of the specific decision.
We should also remember that an independent board member is often the person who asks uncomfortable questions, challenges the company to find more efficient solutions, and is prepared to disagree with questionable decisions.
In my view, constructive but demanding scrutiny of the company and its management by the board usually leads to more mature cooperation and better operational results.
Therefore, when discussing SOE governance, we should not overlook what has already been achieved. Over the past three to five years, we have seen numerous positive examples of state-owned enterprises improving their revenues, profitability, efficiency, and public image.